Monday, October 6, 2008

Guess & Check strategy?

So...Nathan brought home a math paper today for homework. It had several word problems that he was supposed to use the guess and check strategy on. First of all, this is the first time I've ever heard of this. Second, to me it seems like a hard concept for 3rd graders. Even for an adult, it takes a little extra thinking. Here's one of the problems:
A grizzly bear's life span is 7 years more
than a black bear's life span.
The sum of their life spans is 43 years.
What is the life span of the grizzly bear
and the black bear?
See? Even an adult has to really stop and think about it. After about one hour, he finally finished all six problems...yes, I said only six! I wasn't going to just give him the answers, so I made him work through them on his own with my help. Anyway, all this to say that I don't really think this is a necessary concept quite yet. I don't know...sometimes I think California school standards are too high and hard.

3 comments:

Shelby-Grace said...

Hi Jennifer,
I'm enjoying reading about you and your family. Blogs are such a great way to stay in touch and catch up with people you don't always get to see! Looking forward to reading more of your thoughts and happenings :)
Tammy

Kelly said...

That does seem like a bit much. Good job in not just giving him the answers though!

Anonymous said...

That is way to hard! I cannot even figure it out and I am in college. Wow! Stinking California! Come back to Kansas!